Give up wanting to deserve any thanks from anyone, or thinking that anybody can be grateful (Catullus) I believe in one God, the omnipotent Father, maker of heaven and the earth, and of all things visible and invisible (from the Catholic Mass)ĭesine de quoquam quicquam bene velle mereri, aut aliquem fieri posse putare pium Pliable as wax to vice, obstinate under reproof (Horace, in reference to youth)Ĭredo in unum Deum, Patrem omnipotentem, factorem cœli et terræ, visibilium omnium et invisibilium It just means that you're not ideologically perfectly consistent, because nobody is and nobody can be.EUdict dictionary: Latin - English Results for: desine fata Deum flecti sperare precando LatinĬease to hope that the decrees of Heaven can bend to prayer (Virgil)Ĭereus in vitium flecti, monitoribus asper How would you get women more involved in powerlifting or contact team sports or endurance sports when there's obviously a sex hormone advantage but you don't want to encourage PEDs? Is segregation the best way to do that still? Does your utopian ideal even treat "sport" as a measurement of those physical characteristics so heavily linked to sex hormones? What about the history of sports as ways to propagate and enforce gender ideas? There's a lot you could discuss!īut not having a fully-formed perfect consistent utopian idea that you're shooting for does not mean you're too inconsistent to argue against obvious efforts to exclude trans women from all areas of society, sports included, in the here and now. This trans argument rests on appealing to the assumed sensibility of notoriously conservative, bigoted authorities, even as they ban cis women from competing in women's sports on specious grounds.īut lots of people still retain those ideas rather than creating a whole new worldview from scratch. (And if a sport is dominated by women, it's illegitimate for high-level competition, of course.) Black people are excluded because of some hateful poo poo about them being "bred" to have natural advantages that turn out to not exist. So women are too infirm to participate in the sports that they are being harassed out of until womens-only leagues are created. In practice, it turns out that "fairness" in high-level sports is bullshit and largely written on the fly to exclude the minorities that IOC or NCAA or whatever authorities want to exclude. I think a lot of people have essentially dissonant ideas about it, rather than a coherent worldview based on careful consideration, largely because most people do not actually give a poo poo about non-team sports, but do assume that the long-standing authorities must have some sort of reason for their rules, and that reason must be connected to their rhetoric. There's an unresolved, underlying discussion about what it even means to be fair in elite sports. The weirdest thing about this thread is the yo-yo'ing between "there is no performance advantage" and "it doesn't even matter if there's a performance advantage." If your position is the latter then why on earth are you spending 10 pages arguing with someone about the former, when the answer is irrelevant? My brain is bleeding. You answer the question you just asked with an affirmative statement (and not another question), or gently caress off. Can you point to a single trans woman not on HRT who was demanding to be allowed to play at a professional level in women's sports? Because I can point to multiple women, both trans and cis, who've been caught in this witch-hunt. It's important that all of these Just Asking Questions fit into a backdrop of politics where regulators are aggressively targeting children and teenagers and other amateurs.Ībove that, I don't think you have any widespread problems. If you're not testing people for PEDs, you don't have any business intruding on their medical privacy. Should trans women not on HRT be allowed to participate in college+ level women's sports?īelow the professional level (and bear in mind that NCAA D1 and D2 are professional sports in every sense but pay), who cares.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |